Trade Deadline Outlook: Pittsburgh Pirates

MLBTR is kicking off a new series for Front Office subscribers! Over the next few weeks, we’ll go team-by-team and examine every club’s deadline outlook as trade season approaches. There are some teams that’ll be easy to categorize as buyers or sellers, but many still find themselves right on the bubble where their play over the next four to six weeks takes on extra importance.

There’s nuance even for teams that are clearly into buy or sell mode. Where are those organizations from a payroll perspective? Are the buyers all-in for 2025 or just opening a long-term competitive window? Are the sellers committed to a multi-year rebuild, or are they likely to focus only on moving rentals while hanging onto players who are controllable beyond this season? Might the baseball operations leader be on the hot seat, and if so, how could that impact their deadline decisions?

We’ll start the series with a focus on teams that have moved to the far end of the standings, giving a bit more time for the fringe contenders to clarify their plans. We’ll get underway with the Pirates, who are headed to their seventh consecutive losing season.

Record: 29-45 (0.2% playoff probability)

Sell Mode

Impending Free Agents: Andrew Heaney, Isiah Kiner-Falefa, Caleb Ferguson, Tim Mayza, Tommy Pham, Adam Frazier, Andrew McCutchen

The Pirates aren’t likely to trade McCutchen. He has played on a series of one-year deals and has made clear he hopes to retire in Pittsburgh. Unless he has a change of heart and wants to compete for a championship, he’ll stick around. They’d listen on any of the other impending free agents, but they’ll probably have a tough time generating much in the way of returns for Pham, Frazier or Mayza. The former two haven’t hit well in 2025 (Pham, in particular), and Mayza is on the 60-day IL due to a lat strain. He hasn’t pitched since late April and isn’t particularly close to a return.