The MLB All-Star Game stands as a midseason celebration of baseball’s elite talents.
Yet, each year, deserving players are overlooked due to the popularity-driven fan voting system.
In 2025, two such players are the Philadelphia Phillies’ Trea Turner and Kyle Schwarber.
Despite their stellar performances, they were not voted in as starters.
Let’s delve into the statistics that underscore their All-Star worthiness.
Trea Turner’s Consistency in 2025
Trea Turner has been a linchpin for the Phillies, showcasing remarkable consistency. As of July 3, 2025, Turner boasts a .295 batting average, ranking 15th in the league. His 11 home runs and 39 RBIs further highlight his offensive contributions. With an OPS of .800, he stands 53rd among MLB players, reflecting his balanced hitting prowess.
On-Base Skills That Win Games
Turner’s ability to get on base is pivotal for the Phillies’ offense. His .350 OBP indicates a keen eye and disciplined approach at the plate.
This on-base proficiency sets the stage for the power hitters behind him, facilitating scoring opportunities and applying constant pressure on opposing pitchers.
Speed That Shifts the Game
Speed remains one of Turner’s most formidable assets. In 2025, he has successfully stolen 21 bases, underscoring his threat on the basepaths. His sprint speed of 30.2 feet per second ranks him among the fastest in the league, turning singles into doubles and consistently challenging defenses.
Defensive Value That Goes Unnoticed
Defensively, Turner continues to excel at shortstop. His fielding metrics, including a high Outs Above Average (OAA), reflect his range and reliability.
Such defensive prowess not only prevents runs but also instills confidence in the pitching staff, knowing that ground balls are in safe hands.
Kyle Schwarber’s Power Output in 2025
Kyle Schwarber’s 2025 season has been nothing short of explosive. With 25 home runs, he is tied for 4th in the league, showcasing his ability to change the game’s complexion with a single swing. His .923 OPS ranks 9th, emphasizing his slugging capabilities.
Schwarber’s Clutch Factor
Schwarber’s knack for delivering in high-pressure situations is evident.
His 57 RBIs place him tied for 11th in the league, many of which have come in crucial moments, turning tight games in the Phillies’ favor.
Veteran Leadership in the Clubhouse
Beyond statistics, Schwarber’s leadership is invaluable. His experience and mentorship have been instrumental in guiding younger players and fostering a winning culture within the clubhouse. Such intangible qualities often go unnoticed but are vital for team cohesion and success.
The Fan Vote Dilemma
The All-Star selection process, heavily influenced by fan votes, often overlooks consistent performers in favor of more popular names. Both Turner and Schwarber, despite their impressive stats, have fallen victim to this trend, highlighting a flaw in the current voting system.
The Reserve Spots Still Matter
While not voted in as starters, the All-Star Game’s reserve spots offer a chance for deserving players to be recognized. Given their 2025 performances, both Turner and Schwarber make compelling cases for inclusion, ensuring the game’s roster truly reflects the season’s top talents.
A Fan’s All-Star Experience
While Phillies fans may be disappointed not to see their hometown stars leading the All-Star starting lineup (yet), there’s still plenty of familiar faces to cheer for. From former Phillies standouts to rival NL East players, the Midsummer Classic always delivers top-tier baseball.
And for fans in Pennsylvania, the action doesn’t stop at watching — with PA sports betting promos, you can get in on the game. Whether you’re backing a familiar face or placing a fun wager on the Home Run Derby, it’s never been easier to add extra excitement to the All-Star festivities.
The Final Word on Deserving Recognition
Leave the politics of popularity behind — if the All-Star Game is meant to showcase the best in baseball, then Trea Turner and Kyle Schwarber cannot be left off the final roster. This is not about sentiment.
It’s about numbers, impact, and presence. One is a relentless sparkplug who rewrites the game with speed and efficiency. The other is a thunderous slugger whose bat tilts the balance every time he steps up.
If Major League Baseball wants integrity in its showcase, it needs to correct the fan vote’s blind spots.
These two aren’t just statistical standouts — they’re the pulse of a contender.
Excluding them would say more about the flaws in selection than their undeniable merit. Now is the time to reward performance over profile.
Put them in. Let them show why they never needed a vote to prove they belonged.
PHOTO: —
The post Overlooked, Not Undeserving: Turner and Schwarber’s All-Star Case appeared first on Philadelphia Sports Nation.